« Carnivorous Plant of the Month Club | Home | Dunhill Bespoke Leather iPod Speakers »
December 18, 2006
No More Dirty Dancing — Episode 2: Haven't we heard this song before?
I thought this kerfuffle was put to rest last year but I guess I was wrong.
Just yesterday in the New York Times, Michelle York's article about the resurgence of the "Dance Nice or Not at All" — as the headline of her story read — movement captured my fancy.
Here's the piece, rehashing the same old same old.
- High Schools Crack Down: Dance Nice or Not at All
Before Sophie Friedman, 15, went to her first high school dance last year, her friends warned her: This would not be like those in middle school with shy, awkward dance moves.
But their advice did not prepare Sophie for what she saw when she showed up. "It was a pretty big shock," she said. "I didn't expect it to be that crazy."
Her classmates were bumping, grinding, shaking, arching, teasing and flaunting in a way that made the chaperons gape.
Since then, the moves have become more risqué, so much so that the principal at Sophie's school, Fayetteville-Manlius High School, in a Syracuse suburb, canceled one dance and banned what he called pornographic dancing styles.
"If you watch this stuff, you end up seeing girls playing out, or being forced to play out, sexually submissive roles," said the principal of the 1,600-student school, James Chupaila. "I don't think a public school should be allowing that to happen."
Not surprising, most of the students — who view their moves as nothing worse than what they see on music videos — were outraged. But across the country, more and more principals are taking a similar line.
In September, the principal of Aliso Niguel High School in Aliso Viejo, Calif., ended a dance early and canceled others until he could be assured that students would not be simulating sex on the dance floor.
Since then, the principal there, Charles Salter, says he has received hundreds of supportive e-mail messages from other principals.
"It's not just a challenge here at our school; it's New Hampshire, Virginia, Ohio and Washington," Mr. Salter said. "I've received e-mails from private Christian schools. There's almost a feeling of helplessness."
But students, and even some parents, have heatedly complained.
"People compare it to the fox trot," Mr. Salter said. "They compare it to Elvis Presley. Uh, that was a little different."
He formed a committee of parents, staff members and students, who came up with a contract for school dances that includes a ban on what is called freak dancing or grinding — and adding a lot more chaperons.
"If I start seeing inappropriateness again, I will cancel dances again," Mr. Salter said. "Students know it's not an idle threat."
In Manlius, school administrators say they have been hearing complaints from chaperons for two years. "Initially we took the approach that many schools had taken, which was to ask kids to stop," Mr. Chupaila said.
That did not work.
But after a number of students complained of being swept into the throngs of dancers and groped, the father of one high school girl, who is a lawyer, cautioned Mr. Chupaila that the situation was ripe for a sexual harassment lawsuit. By allowing the dances to continue, he said, the district left itself open to a lawsuit for creating a hostile environment.
During a homecoming dance in October, chaperons again tried to stop students from performing some of their more suggestive moves, but the students rebelled.
"If you tell a kid to do something, they do what they want to anyway and probably do it 10 times more," said Emily Bragdon, 16, a junior who was at the dance.
She likes to freak dance and does not see anything wrong with it. "I try to keep it so that if a little kid was watching, he wouldn't be disgusted," she said. "But other people don't keep it PG. For our generation, sex is more casual. It sounds bad to say it, but it's true."
Mr. Chupaila, 60, who admits to doing the twist in high school, has been the object of some withering criticism since canceling this month's dance.
"I think it's kind of ridiculous," Robert F. Byrne, 15, said. "Our administration is refusing to change with the times."
I dunno: Prohibition worked really well and the war on drugs is a great success so maybe cracking down on teenagers doing what teenagers do is the way to go.
Fayetteville-Manlius High School Principal James Chupaila (below)
did admit to doing the twist in high school but of course this time around — as always — it's a totally different thing.
Right.
David Byrne got it right: same as it ever was.
December 18, 2006 at 02:01 PM | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c5dea53ef00d834d14c1453ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference No More Dirty Dancing — Episode 2: Haven't we heard this song before?:
Comments
Oh generation of harlots and shameless men. Oh shameless adulterer parents.. It wont be long before you find yourselves in the pit of hell. Repent and follow the path that leads to righteousness. Accept the free gift of salvation offered by God today. Accept Jesus Christ as your savior now.. Don't wait till its too late.Ask Jesus to come into your life and make you the person you should be. Read John 3:16 in the bible.
Posted by: Don Joe | Mar 29, 2008 1:24:53 PM
I think it'd be interesting to know who in this discussion has children. A lot of people not only change their opinions when they become parents, but their behavior as well. And what would y'all do about the above-mentioned problem of girls being groped against their will?
Posted by: Kiwi the Geek | Dec 23, 2006 4:01:45 AM
I think us adults are just jealous that we can't be the ones doing the 'dirty dancing' today. What would people think if we actually did that?
Now I do have to say that after a long sleep I did finally wake up and go on a girls night out. Well let me tell ya what some adults do on the dance floor these days actually made me blush. But then again they are consenting adults. Much like the teenagers. Only their momma and daddy didn't consent for them to do the same thing they are doing. What a double standard we live in. Do as I say ...not as I do?
Posted by: Rhonda | Dec 20, 2006 12:06:56 PM
I thought this was so over in 2004, but I guess I was wrong.
Grinding, freaking, dirty dancing--eh, it does go a bit far, especially if one of the dancers is supine on the dance floor.
Posted by: Liz | Dec 19, 2006 1:44:03 PM
Malaysia has the solution :-(
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2006/12/17/nation/16348816&sec=nation
PAS-style dance clubs
BY IAN MCINTYRE
KOTA BARU: Mentri Besar Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat has given his blessings to an Islamic form of dance clubs to serve as entertainment outlets here.
He said, however, no liquor would be served and there must be a segregation of the male and female patrons.
There must also be proper attire for women such as clothes that do not reveal the navel, Nik Abdul Aziz told reporters here yesterday.
His remarks came after state local government committee chairman Takiyuddin Hassan said the state government could consider applications for entertainment outlets under the proposed tourism zone in Kuala Besar, near the Pantai Cahaya Bulan stretch.
The zone will have tourism attractions like a state-of-the-art cultural centre, a marina, local cuisine speciality restaurants, handicrafts and souvenir outlets.
He saida discotheque or nightclub would not be allowed since it was against the spirit of its entertainment laws.
Nik Abdul Aziz said he was not opposed to dancing but that couples should not do it and most importantly, that the women's navel was covered.
He said that entertainment was allowed in Islam but with certain conditions so that it did not lead to social ills, he said.
He added that Muslim women must be covered from head to toe except for their face and hands while Muslim men must be decently dressed when in public.
State PAS Youth head Salahuddin Ayub said the party was trying to demonstrate a healthy form of entertainment in the Islamic context.
He said PAS leaders should not give up on their quest despite criticisms from certain quarters and attempts by Umno to politicise it.
Salahuddin said the wing will also meet with foreign tourists to find out what kind of entertainment activities they like in the country.
He said this was important for the Visit Malaysia Year 2007 and the Visit Kelantan 2008 campaigns.
Posted by: Bushido | Dec 18, 2006 8:29:55 PM
If some old farts just MUST stop some kids from enjoying a dance or two, there's a real easy way -- John Belushi talked about it (although he was referring to smoking dope, not dancing) back in the day. All they need to do is turn up on the dance floor themselves and crank out a grind. Really get into it -- moan & groan, lots of pelvis action, lewd expressions. The kids would watch that for maybe five minutes before they'd want to puke. "Oh God, the fossils are at it! There's no way in hell this can be cool now! Yeeech! Bleeech! Aaaarrrrgh!" And then they'd invent some real sedate moves, performed about five feet apart, that incorporate code gestures understood only by teenagers, and that have filthier meanings than any dance the wardens can possibly imagine. Heh heh.
Posted by: Flautist | Dec 18, 2006 5:50:04 PM

