« Pocket Wrench | Home | Cup-Pilot »

November 01, 2008

What if commenters had to provide their real names — and Social Security numbers?

7ouu9p

You don't think much of that idea, do you?

Oh, did I understate things?

In South Korea "To battle online harassment, the government’s Communications Commission last year ordered Web portals with more than 300,000 visitors a day to require its users to submit their names and matching Social Security numbers before posting comments."

I learned this in Choe Sang-Hun's October 12, 2008 New York Times story about the recent suicide of South Korean movie star Choi Jin-sil (above), for years the subject of relentless online attacks and insults about her status as a single divorced mother.

The Times article follows.

    Korean Star’s Suicide Reignites Debate on Web Regulation

    Choi Jin-sil, a movie star, was the closest thing South Korea had to a national sweetheart.

    So when Ms. Choi, 39, was found dead in her apartment on Oct. 2 in what the police concluded was a suicide, her grief-stricken homeland sought an answer to why the actress had chosen to end her life.

    The police, the media and members of Parliament immediately pointed fingers at the Internet. Malicious online rumors led to Ms. Choi’s suicide, the police said, after studying memos found at her home and interviewing friends and relatives.

    Those online accusations claimed that Ms. Choi, who once won a government medal for her savings habits, was a loan shark. They asserted that a fellow actor, Ahn Jae-hwan, was driven to suicide because Ms. Choi had relentlessly pressed him to repay a $2 million debt.

    Public outrage over Ms. Choi’s suicide gave ammunition to the government of President Lee Myung-bak, which has long sought to regulate cyberspace, a major avenue for antigovernment protests in South Korea.

    Earlier this year, the Lee government was reeling after weeks of protests against beef imports from the United States. Vicious antigovernment postings and online rumors on the dangers of lifting the ban on American beef fueled the political upheaval, which forced the entire cabinet to resign.

    In a monthlong crackdown on online defamation, 900 agents from the government’s Cyber Terror Response Center are scouring blogs and online discussion boards to identify and arrest those who “habitually post slander and instigate cyber bullying.”

    Hong Joon-pyo, floor leader of the governing Grand National Party, commented, “Internet space in our country has become the wall of a public toilet.”

    In the National Assembly, Ms. Choi’s suicide set the country’s rival parties on a collision course over how to regulate the Web. The governing party is promoting a law to punish online insults; the opposition parties accuse the government of trying to “rule cyberspace with martial law.”

    The opposition says that cyberspace violence is already dealt with under existing laws against slander and public insults. But the government says that a tougher, separate law is necessary to punish online abuse, which inflicts quicker and wider damage on victims.

    To battle online harassment, the government’s Communications Commission last year ordered Web portals with more than 300,000 visitors a day to require its users to submit their names and matching Social Security numbers before posting comments.

    The police reported 10,028 cases of online libel last year, up from 3,667 reported in 2004.

    Harassment in cyberspace has been blamed for a string of highly publicized suicides. Ms. Choi made headlines when she married a baseball player, Cho Sung Min, in 2000. But tabloids and Web bloggers were relentless in criticizing her when the marriage soured and she fought for custody of her two children.

    TV producers and commercial sponsors dropped her. The general sentiment was that her career was over.

    But in 2005, she made a comeback with a hugely popular soap opera called “My Rosy Life.” In it, she dropped her cute-girl image and played a jilted wife who throws a kick at her errant husband, but reconciles with him when she learns she has terminal cancer.

    This year, she broke another taboo by successfully petitioning a court to change the surname of her two children to her own.

    But in an interview with MBC-TV in July, which was broadcast after her death, she said she “dreaded” the Internet, where posters had insulted her for being a single, divorced mother. The police said she had been taking antidepressants since her divorce.

    In South Korea, volunteer counselors troll the Internet to discourage people from using the Web to trade tips on how to commit suicide and, in some cases, how to form suicide pacts.

    “We have seen a sudden rise in copycat suicides following a celebrity death,” said Jeon Jun-hee, an official at the Seoul Metropolitan Mental Health Center, which runs a suicide prevention hot line. Mr. Jeon said the hot line had received 60 calls a day, or twice the usual number, since Ms. Choi’s suicide.

digg facebook stumble reddit delicios twitter November 1, 2008 at 04:01 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c5dea53ef010535cea1dd970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What if commenters had to provide their real names — and Social Security numbers? :

Comments

With all of the Korean celeb sucides, it sounds to me like there's a much greater issue then people making comments.

"As some of you may or may not already know, early this month, top Korean actress Choi Jin-sil comitted suicide by hanging herself at her home in Seoul. She was 39. It was reported that she had suffered from depression since her 2002 seperation, and messy divorce two years later, from her pro-baseball player husband and was upset by recent rumors (she claimed were false) that she had loaned a large sum of money to an actor friend and was pressuring him to pay it back, which was a reasom he commited suicide in early September. I suppose the alcohol she had to drink that evening also helped with her decision to take her own life.

Although Jin-shil's death shocked many, it wasn't the first time a high profile Korean entertainer has comitted suicide in recent years."

Depression since 2002 due to a messy divorce, ad recently a friend of hers killed himself. I'm sure that the rumors didn't help at all, but it's not like she was happy and chipper every day untill she found the internet.

You can read more about Korea celeb deaths at
http://www.asian-sirens.com/blog/comments.php?id=1818_0_1_0_C

but site is NSFW...

Posted by: Rocketboy | Nov 3, 2008 7:05:59 AM

It is the most elementary struggle of society, how to prevent cruelty and other forms of violence. Some of us are pretty safe physically just now, but the internet has risen as a sort of lake of gasoline. Ten years ago, it was flame wars on private listserves, or just between individuals, meanness and name-calling I had never seen happen face to face or in snail mail. Now, anger and name-calling can flare all over the world at once.

And this other thing, gossip that delights in tearing down the famous. What's to be done? I am reminded of grade school, where rowdy boys were sometimes told, If you don't settle down, I'll punish the whole class. It does work that way.

Posted by: majeanne | Nov 1, 2008 10:34:59 PM

The Wall Street Journal has a similar comment policy. They don't require your SS#, but they do require a PAID subscription if you want to comment. This policy drastically minimizes the quantity of comments on their stories (as compared to, say, they NY Times), but greatly improves the signal to noise ratio. Unfortunately, the footsteps (especially those of less well-heeled readers) are drowned out along with the "noise."

Posted by: Todd | Nov 1, 2008 6:19:05 PM

This could never happen here in America. **

** Brought to by --- AT$T and the National Security Agency, equal inopportunity employers.

Posted by: NSA | Nov 1, 2008 5:57:42 PM

Post a comment