« BehindTheMedspeak: Miracle Nose Cones (no — it's not rocket science) | Home | Time Tool »

January 14, 2009

A modest proposal

Fhgiyugh

After yet another round of familiar, boring commercials during  this past weekend's NFL playoffs, I was once again struck by the inability of both corporations and their ad agencies to move beyond the dead, zombified concept of showing the same commercial over and over and over during a show, to the point where the unfortunate viewer sometimes will see the identical spot three, four, even five times within a given half hour.

I say again: This is no different than telling the same joke repeatedly and expecting the audience to laugh with every rendition as if they'd just heard it for the first time.

And when the joke is bad to begin with, why, you're really taking your product down to a place you don't want it to go in your prospective customer's psyche.

But enough whining, joe — how about offering something positive instead of more of the same old refrain?

OK.

Here's my suggestion: Instead of spending millions of dollars to create a car commercial where some vehicle pulls an airplane or a train — true, this is a situation most of us run into every now and again — why not take the money and dole it out to people who'll create commercials so cheaply that each one need air only once before heading to its YouTube channel?

No, I'm not advocating a contest like a number of brands have already done, to supplement their main advertising thrust; rather, I'm saying junk the main event and go with the alternatives.

Because the current model died when YouTube was born.



January 14, 2009 at 12:01 PM | Permalink


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c5dea53ef010536ccf007970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A modest proposal:

Comments

I [vaguely] recall some company suing one of the [then] Big 2 for showing its commercial more than once during the same show. OK to do it more than once an evening, but NOT on the same show.

But then, I am old enough to remember when there was an outcry against Gunsmoke for going too far as an "adult" Western ("Is MIss Kitty A Fallen Woman?"). Heck, I am old enough to remember shows with commercials for only one company, which sponsored it.

Gack! I try to forget my advanced age, but keep getting reminded.

Posted by: teqjack | Jan 14, 2009 11:24:45 PM

Off major topic (whadja expect), but to echo the second half of Mary Sue's comment -- only commercial that ever got funnier every time I saw it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-FYGmMzwJRA

Posted by: Flautist | Jan 14, 2009 10:54:48 PM

They repeat the commercials to combat TiVo, which even my local sports pub is using now on the big screen for the big games.

The big advertising agencies do not have the flexibility, creatively nor fiscally, to embrace YouTube format. They still work off of old business models, and no one's been able to produce a sure-fire business model for YouTube/Internet video advertising. Until they can prove the money is there within a certain percentage of profit, they'll keep plodding away at their old ways.

Having said that, there was one commercial that showed about half a dozen times an hour during the Christmas Day Basketball Marathon that I laughed at every time. It was for an insurance agency, and a guy's car had been broken into. And his friends were making fun of him because the only thing that wasn't stolen was a Kid N Play CD. Then the friends were in the background doing the jig.

I laughed and laughed. The several beers I'd had probably added to the humor.

Posted by: Mary Sue | Jan 14, 2009 1:55:45 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.